Theo's Eatery

214 Memorial Ave., Orillia
Image of Theo's Eatery
About Theo's Eatery:

Specializing in Italian, Greek and Canadian cuisine, Theo’s Eatery is located on 2014 Memorial Avenue, in Orillia, Ontario. It serves a lot of house-made items like their pizza along with other interesting food choices.

The eatery takes reservations, does deliveries and has its own parking space. It serves lunch and dinner and is big enough to accommodate a larger group of patrons. The menu is varied, ranging from Italian dishes, Greek dishes, to ribs, steaks, and seafood. The food is prepared by experienced personnel, and they offer a lot of options, vegetarian and vegan-friendly, as well as gluten-free meals.

Theo’s Eatery is opened seven days a week; from Monday to Friday it works from 11 AM to 10 PM, and over the weekend it opens at 4 PM with closing time at 10 PM. There is a separate lunch menu available from 11 AM to 3 PM, a dinner menu, as well as a kids menu for kids 10 and under.

This place has received a lot of reviews online on sites like Google Reviews, Yelp, and Trip Advisor. I’ve used these to find the pros and cons which I present below.


  • Great food choices
  • Excellent Italian dishes, Greek and Canadian dishes
  • Reservations, deliveries
  • A casual and more formal dining sections
  • Pleasant décor


  • Notes from people with food allergies
  • Complaints about some dishes

Theo’s Eatery opened in 1993 as a family-run business and it is still to this day. The restaurant is nicely decorated, with tasteful interior and a lot of pleasant details. There are beautiful light fixtures, wood and glass partitions between leather seating booths and nice wooden tables and chairs. There is a nice wooden bar with seating, a smaller dining area and a larger dining room for larger groups.

The menu is divided into a lunch and dinner menu, along with a kids menu. The lunch menu offers different types of sandwiches and wraps, lunch pasta dishes, baked lunch pasta, and melts and mini pizzas. The dinner menu offer everything you can imagine in a mixed cuisine restaurant: garlic bread, calamari, hummus, spanakopita (spinach pita), bruschetta, soups, salads, burgers, stirfry, sandwiches, Greek food like souvlaki, and lamb chops, Tuscan and village pizza, chicken and veal dishes, ribs and steak dishes, classic and oven-baked pasta, seafood like garlic shrimp, maple glazed salmon and fish and chips, housemade pizzas and the option to build your own pizza.

Theo’s Eatery also serves alcohol from its full bar, as well as a good selection of wines that complement the food. This place is very popular with the Orillia people, and it holds a certificate of excellence and is ranked as the third best restaurant in Orillia on Trip Advisor. It is also quite popular over the weekends and as a special occasions dining option, so it is advisable to make a reservation if you want to enjoy a meal at Theo’s Eatery.

Reservations accepted, delivery and take out is also available.

Menu: Features: